Rethinking the Hiring Process: The Case for Personality Assessments

 


In the hiring world, we often prioritize the wrong qualities—focusing on technical skills and domain knowledge while overlooking the core attributes that make a candidate genuinely exceptional. This is especially apparent when the job market constantly evolves, requiring individuals who can learn, adapt, and thrive in the face of new challenges. This is where personality assessments, such as the Hogan Assessment, can transform how we approach hiring.

The Problem with Traditional Hiring Metrics

Traditional hiring practices focus on candidates' technical knowledge, degrees, and certifications. While these are important, they are often overemphasized. Skills like using a particular software or executing specific tasks can be learned on the job. However, adaptability, emotional intelligence, and a candidate’s core personality traits are more difficult to cultivate post-hire. These qualities often indicate a candidate’s long-term success in a role more than their ability to check off technical boxes.

According to research, organizations that use personality assessments in hiring processes benefit from improved employee performance, retention, and overall engagement. This suggests we shift our focus from purely technical competencies to measuring qualities indicating a candidate's potential to grow and evolve.

Why Personality Assessments Work

Tools like the Hogan Assessment, used in leadership hiring and development, measure fundamental personality traits such as ambition, sociability, and prudence. These assessments probe how people think, work in teams, and handle pressure—all qualities that technical interviews or skill tests often miss.

A personality assessment can help determine whether a candidate will:

  • Adapt to change effectively

  • Engage in lifelong learning

  • Work well within the existing organizational culture

  • Stay resilient in the face of challenges

When companies hire for core qualities like emotional intelligence and adaptability, they hire individuals who are likely to stay with the company longer and grow with its evolving needs.

Connecting Personality Assessments to Education Hiring

The same principles apply to education, where the stakes are arguably higher. Schools face continuous challenges, from evolving educational standards to a rapidly changing world. Hiring teachers, administrators, and support staff with the right core qualities—beyond technical or subject matter expertise—becomes essential for long-term success.

Take school administrators, for example. As I noted in my work on the 360-degree feedback tool for administrators, integrating personality assessments into hiring processes could enhance our understanding of a candidate’s leadership potential, emotional resilience, and ability to handle the unique challenges of working in education. Administrators must navigate complex relationships, handle high-pressure situations, and constantly adapt to new educational policies and technologies. Hiring someone with the right personality traits, such as flexibility, problem-solving abilities, and social intelligence, can make all the difference.

Moreover, using tools like Hogan or other psychological inventories would provide hiring committees with deeper insights into how school staff will work within a team, relate to students, and engage in problem-solving. It's a powerful complement to traditional interviews focusing solely on job-specific skills or knowledge.

The Potential Impact on School Systems

Consider the broader impact of such an approach. School districts constantly grapple with retention issues and finding talent that aligns with their long-term vision. An effective administrator, teacher, or support staff member is proficient in their technical role and understands the emotional and social aspects of working in an educational environment. For instance, someone who aligns with the school’s mission and values will foster positive relationships, stay motivated, and contribute meaningfully to the school community.

By using personality assessments in hiring, schools can make more intelligent, sustainable hiring decisions. This could alleviate some of the challenges associated with high turnover rates and poor cultural fits that are common in educational institutions today.

As I explore in my article on school board elections, understanding the complex systems within schools is critical to making informed decisions. That principle holds in hiring, too. Including personality assessments ensures we consider the whole person, not just the technical skills they bring.

Conclusion: Hiring for the Future, Not Just for Today

Using personality assessments in hiring should be more than a nice to have. They can be a game-changer in building effective teams in general industries and educational systems. By shifting our focus to core qualities like adaptability, emotional intelligence, and problem-solving ability, we set up our organizations for long-term success.

It’s time we rethink the hiring process and focus on traits that predict future success. When we hire candidates who are adaptable, resilient, and capable of learning, we invest in the future of our schools and organizations—not just the present.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Testing Smarter, Not Harder

Image
  I understand the value of assessments. Testing can be a powerful tool for measuring student growth, diagnosing learning gaps, and informing instructional strategies. Yet, over the years, I’ve grown increasingly frustrated by how mandated assessments encroach upon valuable instructional time. As an administrator, I ensured compliance with state and district testing mandates, often prioritizing accountability metrics over meaningful classroom activities. I struggled with the volume of assessments and their impact on students and teachers. Too often, I found myself questioning the purpose of specific tests. Did every assessment genuinely provide value to students and teachers, or were some simply fulfilling bureaucratic requirements? All too frequently, it felt like the latter. The problem isn’t that testing exists — it’s how it dominates the school calendar: preparation, administration, and make-up testing swallow weeks of instructional time. Teachers, already stretched thin, are o...
Read more

Maximizing Educational Opportunities: Strategies for Navigating the Hybrid Learning Frontier

Image
  Maximizing Educational Opportunities: Strategies for Navigating the Hybrid Learning Frontier As an educator, I’ve witnessed the evolution of learning modalities over the past two decades. My journey with online education began when I was a high school principal at a large suburban school in metro Detroit, working on my doctorate. My dissertation, titled  High School Student Engagement in Online and On-Ground Courses , which I completed in July 2015, offered me a valuable glimpse into the growing role of online learning in high school education. At the time, the idea of hybrid and fully online education was still in its infancy, especially compared to today's post-pandemic world. Back then, online learning felt like a distant future for many school districts; even those embracing it were only scratching the surface. Fast forward to 2020, and the entire education landscape was irrevocably transformed by the COVID-19 pandemic. Schools across the globe were forced to pivot to on...
Read more

Global Competence in K-12 Education: Preparing Students for an Interconnected World

Image
  I read  The World is Flat by  Thomas Friedman sometime in the mid-2000s. While I had an appreciation for different cultures and a vague understanding of the world’s interconnectedness—I didn’t contemplate it much. I recall Friedman’s book stretching my thinking, detailing the rapid changes brought about by technology, global trade, and interconnected economies. Since then, we have witnessed an accelerated “flattening” fueled by advancements in communication and the rise of social media. What involvement should schools play in fostering global competence? Education is about preparing students for the future, which is undeniably global. By fostering global competence in K-12 classrooms, we guide the next generation in meeting the challenges of an interconnected world with confidence, creativity, and compassion.  By embedding global themes into the curriculum, students develop critical thinking skills to analyze issues from multiple viewpoints. Language learning enhan...
Read more